Pakistan’s preperation for WC2011
on October 29th, 2010 at 4:59 amWorld cup 2011 is just a few months away, all the major teams except Pakistan have already completed their preperations and have finalized their pool of players for the WC 2011. During this remaining time before the world cup these teams are trying different game plans and different combinations.
Whereas, Pakistan has never been so disintegrated, the loss of Aamer, Asif and Butt is huge and there is no chance that they will be available for selection for the WC. Under the circumstances any other board foreseeing the problem would have immediately started the rebuilding process, but PCB just chose to recall all the old discarded players back.
If we look at the team playing against South Africa just add Inzamam, Shoaib Malik, Imran Nazir and Rao Iftikhar to it and it will almost become the same team which lost to Ireland in 2007 WC.
The above scenario raises the question that since the last WC how many players of international calibre PCB has developed? Two years ago they told us that they have started preparing for the world cup where is the result?
The fact is that the academy has given us just Aamer and Umar Akmal the rest is just trash. Aamer has self destructed and Umar Akmal has failed to live upto his reputation. The current team is a lot weaker than the team which went to the carribean under Inzi in 2007.
Whatever was gained during the last five years has been lost due to the corrupt culture internal politics and inconsistent and unfair selection policies.
We developed Salman Butt and kamran Akmal as openers in the shorter format both are out of the team due to corruption. The middle order used to be the backbone of Pakistan’s batting under Nasim Ashraf’s administration but due to dirty politics all four middle order batsmen have been in and out of the team during the last year and have played international cricket occassionally, Younis and Misbah are making a come back after almost a year, Malik is still out of the team due to poor form, Yousaf during the last two years have also been in and out of the team first due to ICL exodus and later because of his retirement.
Umar Akmal, Fawad Alam, Asad Shafiq, and Azhar Ali were added to the national team during last two years but except Umar Akmal neither one has the talent to be successful at international level, Shafiq is promising but has very little experience.
The selection has been very unfair and inconsistent during the last two years, we don’t have a proper opening pair, Imran Farhat, Khalid Lateef, Khurram Manzoor, Shahzaib Hassan and Hafeez have failed consistently. Taufeeq Umar, Imran Nazir, Nasir Jamshed, and Ahmad Shahzad are the back up openers. All four of them consistently performed better than Yasir hameed and Imran Farhat in domestic tournaments but they couldn’t impress the selectors.
Kamran Akmal will probably make a comeback but who will be his partner, the selectors had the current series to try out Nazir and Ahmad Shahzad but they preferred Farhat and Hafeez I think it was an opportunity lost to repair some damage.
Younis, Umar Akmal, Misbah, Yousaf, Afridi and Razzaq will form the middle order.
There is no replacement player for Afridi and Razzaq we are stuck with them, PCB hasn’t made any effort in developing new all rounders over the years those who had the potential have been completely ignored.
If we look at England, Australia, South Africa and India they have developed new players for every position during the last two years and have also given them enough exposure at international level to help mature them.
PCB also tried many young faces but not even a single player was ready for International cricket they all were talented but with the exception of Fawad Alam and Omar Akmal not even a single player got a longer run, one failure and the player was discarded.
Our team looks like a veterans eleven, the aging players are making a comeback so they need match practice it won’t be possible for Pakistan team to expose it’s young players to the test that would be another lost opportunity. South Africa very smartly rested the older players in the T20′s and played their upcoming players, PCB should have done the same.
The biggest blow to Pakistan team’s chance in WC was the loss of Aamer and Asif the pair alongwith Shoaib and Gul would have made the best and most versatile pace attack in the world but now our only hope is Akhtar.
If Pakistan has to fancy any chances of reaching the final four in the world cup they will have to follow an aggressive approach and will have to take some bold steps to carve a winning combination out of its depleted resources.
PCB will have to let go of policies of favoritism and nepotism.
They will have to pick Nazir and Ahmad Shahzad as openers, Farhat should get dropped. We can’t allow Hafeez to bat at #3 or #1 he doesn’t last more than 4 overs. We also can’t afford two all rounders who are only good at one skill, it would be better to play specialist players instead.
Afridi leadership should be closely monitored during this series.
The selectors should monitor the performance of players not on the basis of statistics but only on the basis of their effectiveness on the field and the success they achieved in terms of their role.

I don’t think that todays victory will boost Pakistan’s morale it was not Pakistan teams victory it was just Razzaq winning against South Africa, it’s hard to find matches in recent history where Pakistan won a match due to team effort yes we have won quite a few due to individual performances.
Which makes me wonder why certain players get back in form when they are about to get axed from the team.
South Africa won’t have much to think they will drop Patterson and Albie Morkel and will play Rusty theron and Smith.
But Pakistan will have to fix their top order batting if they have to challenge south Africa, Asad Shafiq will sit out and Umar Akmal might return. I would really want to see Shahzaib back in the team.
But thats not possible unless the management decides to drop Misbah.
Did I mentioned that Ahmad Shahzad has scored 330 runs in his last two innings playing for HBl in QEA trophy.
PCB
Malik just yesterday gave a statement about Afridi’s captaincy after that I don’t think Afridi would want him. Anyway’s we as fans like to forgive and forget and have short term memory. Whatever you said about Malik’s experience and his skills is more or less right except that I don’t think he is a better batsman than Shahzad or Hafeez based on his recent form also I don’t have any reason to believe that he has been reformed and won’t create any problems for the current or future captains.
I agree that Sohail Tanvir is inconsistent but so is Rana don’t you agree. I only had Tanvir as a reserve just in case one of the fast bowlers get unfit. Rana admitted himself on tape that he deliberately underperformed under Younis just for that sole reason I don’t want him in the team I have seen him on many occassions underperforming and not playing to his potential that is why he won’t get my vote.
If I was a selector I would pick Junaid Khan buut I think he is a bit raw at this stage and there is not much time left to groom him the guy is just like Aamer when he made his debut only a bit quicker.
The problem is that you guys havent seen domestic cricket and have not seen Shahzaib hitting every front line Pakistani bowler out of the park, Shahzaib played at least three innings like the one Razzaq played today in Faysal bank tournament. He is just a bit nervous and his nervousness can be cured if he is played more consistently right now results are not important the most important thing is that we give exposure to our best players before the world cup and allow them to get into groove.
Shahzaib was also in reserves my first choice was Nazir like you the only difference in top three between your 11 and mine was Malik, I don’t think anybody will have confidence in Malik batting at #3 based on his last 2 years performance.
Wahab Riaz has to be in the team even if we have to drop Gul he is a better bowler and will get even better with time.The only difference here is that you are picking Giul based on his past form and I am picking Wahab based on his current form he is in much better rythym as compared to GUL who has a habit of bowling a few bad balls every over half of his over is brilliant and half is pathetic sign of a bowler who is struggling with form and fitness.
Don’t take me wrong here Gul has been one of my all time favorite bowler but right now he is not what he was last year.
Hafeez is much better bowler than Malik but both have the same problem they get out in 20′s and 30′s this problem is more perennial with Malik than Hafeez.
If Ajmal didn’t improve his form Pakistan would be better off playing Hafeez instead. Hafeez is also one of my reserves.
Razzaq played a gem of an innings only he could have played an innings like this, this innings will be my all time favorite innings in Odi cricket as he single handedly won the match from a team like SA there was no way Pakistan could have won it after Afridi and Fawad got out but it was a freaky innings something like Hussey played against Pakistan but this one was better in many ways.
Having said this, the problem with playing Razzaq as an all rounder remains the same, he is fine as a batsman but his bowling is a gift for the opposition if we can find a way to play him as a batsman only then I am fine with it but playing him as the sixth bowler disrupts the teams balance, besides his batting is inconsistent partly because he bats too late down the order and every time the pressure is on him and Afridi to play some big miraculous innings, both players are more like pinch hitters one extra ordinary ball or the slightest error made by them and they are done. There is a high risk of failure associated with players of this breed although Razzaq can bat sensibly if he bats higher he knows how to change gears whereas Afridi knows only one style of batting.
I think the only two players which might not get selected in my squad are Ahmad Shahzad and Sohail Tanvir. And if PCB decided to scew up things then they might drop Nazir and Shahzaib also to accomodate Farhat and Fawad. They will probably pick Misbah in place of Shahzad.
Malik used to be a troublemaker but I don’t think he is anymore – Waqar Younis and Shahid Afridi both wanted him for SA matches. I still think Rana is better than Sohail Tanvir because Sohail Tanvir is too erratic in his performances and so not reliable/established/proven enough for the WC.
I think Malik is better than Ahmed Shahzad not only in batting, but Malik is more than useful with the bowl and a brilliant fielder. Also don’t underestimate his experience and how crucial that will be for Pakistan. The team you published could mean a very instable top 3. Shahzaib and Shahzad are both for the future and need to be given more A tours.
Wahab Riaz bowled excellently today, but I would still stick to the team I have named above, with Wahab only part of the 15. If he continues to perform, he then should be considered.
The only problem with Hafeez is that he gets set and gets out wheres Malik has the ability to play big innings and keep the scoreboard ticking – a bit like Younis and Yousuf, although Hafeez is probably a better bowler than Malik.
Ajmal was below par today but this is one bad performance after many many good ones and also he was slightly unlucky with edges and missed chances.
I think if we persist with players such as Kamran Akmal, Umar Akmal, Imran Nazir, Shoaib Malik, Afridi and Razzaq, then consistency will come – e.g. people are putting pressure on Afridi and whilst I would prefer Younis as capt, if we carry on changing captains then the players keep changing as well as tactics and the roles of players.
The ultimate difference between our different views of Razzaq is that I have Malik in my side, so Malik and Razzaq can share the 10 overs whereas if you replaced Wahab with Razzaq, then Razzaq would have to bowl 10.
I would think that this team is better balanced than the one below it:
1. Imran Nazir
2. Kamran Akmal (wkt)
3. Shoaib Malik
4. Younis Khan (capt)
5. Mohammad Yousuf
6. Umar Akmal
7. Shahid Afridi
8. Abdul Razzaq
9. Umar Gul
10. Shoaib Akhtar
11. Saeed Ajmal
1-Imran Nazir
2-Kamran Akmal
3-Ahmad Shahzad
4-Younis Khan
5-Yousaf
6- Afridi
7- Umar Akmal
8 – Wahab Riaz
9 – Umar Gul
10- Shoaib
11- Ajmal
The second team relies heavily on Younis and Yousuf, because Nazir, K Akmal and Ahmad Shahzad cannot be relied upon to play long innings. It only has 5 bowlers meaning one can’t have a bad day.
The first team would allow Nazir and K Akmal to express themselves and then allows Malik, Younis, Yousuf and U. Akmal to bat through middle overs with Afridi and Razzaq having a blast at the end.
PCB
I would still not include him as an allrounder. Just on the back of his batting he will win us matches occasionally but if we sacrifice one bowler just because of him it will create a serious handicap.
It is easy to get carried away after performances like this but the reality about his bowling and its negative effect on the team’s combination will remain there we have to play him as a batsman alone.
Great knock by Razzaq single handedly won the match although Afridi and Fawad contributed but it was still next to impossible to win the match when Razzaq came into bat.
His last Odi 50 came in 2006. Nobody expected this kind of an innings from him probably one of the best I have ever seen, I would rank it as great as Miandad’s against India.
Pakistan’s top order flopped once again, with the exception of Yousaf and Younis perhaps there is not even a single classic batsman in Pakistan on whom we can depend or who can fullfill their roles consistently, then we have players like Kamran Akmal, Umar Akmal, Imran Nazir, Shahzaib Hassan, Afridi, and Razzaq these guys are not consistent either maybe even less consistent then the rest but when they click Pakistan wins, This is a big dilema Pakistan faces, are we going to keep on changing players after a cuople of failures or are we going to persist with a combination of proven match winners. If the later then which combination is the most balanced.
We have played players mediocre players who have never won us any match for many years but players like Shazaib, Akmal brothers and Nazir we have no patience for.
Today Pakistan made the tough choice of dropping Umar Gul and bringing in Wahab Riaz it was a difficult decision to take as Gul is a senior player and has been a star player but has lately become less effective, Wahab was superb perhaps it was his spell which pulled SA down and stopped them from reaching 300+.
Afridi’s aggressive innings did a world of good to his team this is what was missing in the first three matches even today he threw away his wicket but he made a healthy contribution this is what is expected of him as a captain and he has to deliver more consistently.
It would be unfair not to appreciate Fawad Alam, who played his role staying within his limitations. His innings was not aggressive he struggled to hit boundaries but was good in rotating the strike something which was required of him today especially when Razzaq and Afridi were firing.
But when the responsibility drops on him to play the big shots that is where he falters and looks a very poor batsman, today in the later part of his innings his footwork improved a bit.
I rest my case about Razzaq’s inclusion!
WOW!
…I need a rest
Ajmal bowled shit today not even a single doosra in five overs. His gave too much width at times and his lenth was also not right.
Stani
He in his debut test he was consistently clocking at 90- 92. In the last test I was surprised why he has cut down on his pace. But over here in Dubai he has been very accurate and quite uncomfirtable to face he hasn’t bowled 90+ here but keep in view the conditions the wickets are dry and slow.
This south African team does have it’s soft spots, Smith is totally out of sorts, Hashim Amla, Jp Duminy and AB are the main batsmen in form. Ingram and Miller are good additions but Pakistan’s bowling hasn’t tested them they were visibily uncomfortable against the spinners. The bowling with the addition of Steyn will become quite good but in Subcontinent conditions and not having a good spinner will eventually hurt them Tsosobe took quite a few wickets against Pakistan but that was more because of poor batting than quality bowling, Morne Morkel and Steyn will be there main bowlers.
They struggled to chase minor totals against Pakistan in T20′s. Even in the last Odi had Pakistan scored 250-260 south Africa could have been in trouble.
Pakistan’s bowling will be even more weak in the test matches, there will be no Aamer, Asif, Akhtar or Afridi.
This South African line up will look even better in the test matches especially Amla will torment Pakistan in test matches.
Pakistan will have to think out of the box here and instead of picking losers like Sami and Kaneria they should keep just two fast bowlers Gul and Wahab and play with three spinners. Pace is no longer our strength especially without Aamer, Asif and Akhtar.
Yes, Wahab has been impressive with his lines. I think this is his pace Wasim, between 86 and 90. He only ever reaches 90+ a couple of balls an innings. I checked it on cricinfo. They have the readings from the Tests in England. Nevertheless, good lines. Funnily enough, if we sort out the batting then Razzaq may have to make way for Riaz maybe.
PCB, not sure I would have Malik back, especially with Hafeez now having cemented his place. Before the requirement Malik satisfied was having an extra person who could turn their arm over. Now we have Hafeez for that. I would take Rana though and give him a kick up the backside.
Riaz has bowled way better than Umar Gul, Akhtar and Razzaq, he was unpredictable, mixed up fuller length with short pitched deliveries but unlike other bowlers he bowled the short stuff right in the rib cage and was genuinely quick. Pakistan will have to fix their batting if they have to accomodate Riaz.
The best bowling combination for Pakistan will be Akhtar, Riaz, Gul, Afridi, Ajmal
Haider missed a run out and an easy stumping today. He is not very quick in removing the bails in last three matches there were several occasions when he missed close run outs.
Excellent reverse swinging yorker by Wahab removed Ingram, Wahab has been impressive he didn’t bowled as fast as he can but was quite accurate.
32% of Ingrams runs came in the third man region Afridi didn’t took any slip and neither he had a deep third man for most part of the game five or six edges went into the slips but our captain still didn’t took a slip. Such tactics leave the bowlers toothless and make them look bad then they really were.
The reason I didn’t selected Malik because he is a trouble maker. Rana sometimes has his good days but overall if you look at his fitness he has become too fat as a result was struggling to bowl with rythym his batting was only good against weak domestic or ICl teams has never done anything for Pakistan team.
Name me one orthodox opener on whom you can safely rely, they are all 10-20 run players so why not persist with Shahzaib and Nazir for a long period of time at least the matches in which they will fire we will win. To prove my point I would quote you the example of Akmal brothers they are much criticized but all the recent matches which we won they were the ones who performed.
Ahmed Shahzad is much better than Malik with the bat, he is aggressive plays with a straight bat has all the shots he will be a good one down player.
In the middle order, I think Malik, Younis, Yousuf, Umar Akmal as definite picks.
I would also prefer Mohammad Hafeez (number 3) and Misbah Ul-Haq (number 4 – 6) in the middle order rather than Asad Shafiq.
I assume it is 15.
Shafiq’s not a opener though guys and I disagree that there are so many better options in our middle to late/middle order that he cannot get in. If Fawad made the last team then surely Shafiq can? I think the way he picks up the singles is invaluable. None of our other players hunt like that.
Is it 15 going to the world cup?
Wasim
I think most of your squad is ok.
I think Ahmad Shahzad and Shahzaib Hasan need more A tours before they can be considered for international cricket. I did say this before the T20′s against SA, and we saw what happened to Shahzaib despite his T20 success.
You have also chosen Sohail Tanvir. I would prefer Rana Naved because I think he is has more consistentcy and variation in ODI’s and a better option with the bat.
I’m not sure why you have omitted Shoaib Malik?
You have also selected Wahab Riaz because of Abdul Razzaq. This is because I have Shoaib Malik in my team as an extra bowler to share overs with Razzaq, but you need Riaz to bowl his 10 overs.
PCB
This would be my team.
1-Imran Nazir
2-Kamran Akmal
3-Ahmad Shahzad
4-Younis Khan
5-Yousaf
6- Afridi
7- Umar Akmal
8 – Wahab Riaz
9 – Umar Gul
10- Shoaib
11- Ajmal
12- Hafeez
13- Razzaq
14- Shahzaib
15- Sohail Tanvir
Stani
I also don’t agree about Shafiq he is just an on side player and tries to drag every thing on the leg side. An opener should have the ability to play straight down the ground and on the off side or else he won’t be successful.
He needs more time he is very confident and that will take him a long way.
One more innings like this and Afridi is sure to lose his captaincy, if Malik or Kamran Akmal had thrown away their wicket like this in three consecutive matches all the media would have been after their blood but it’s a shame that our media is so biased that they haven’t written a single word about Afridi’s pathetic leadership and batting.
Haider also dropped a catch today. I hate Akmal brothers but we can’t win a single Odi match without them.
I disagree about Shafiq. I think that he still needs more A tours to develop and we have better options both opening and in the middle order.
I think Kamran Akmal is a must for the world cup because it is important for the balance of the team. Generally, his keeping ODI’s has been fine. I think he suffers from a combination of concentration and technical issues in tests.
What would be your squads for the WC?
Gotta bring Nazir back.
Afridi is really beginning to p me off. Isnt this the same guy that got what was it…two centuries in the asia cup? For a captain his batting mindset is shockingly careless.
We need to stick with Shafiq guys. He is a ballsy player and I would definitely take him to the WC. Not sure about Akmal. If they want to keep him then only as a batsmen. Dropped catches in tournament format are even more costly. Haider…or anyone with two hands as keeper for me.
Yes, sorry Younis as captain for ODI and tests. I also assume Butt, Amir and Asif are ineligible.
1. Imran Nazir
2. Kamran Akmal (wkt)
3. Shoaib Malik
4. Younis Khan (capt)
5. Mohammad Yousuf
6. Umar Akmal
7. Shahid Afridi
8. Abdul Razzaq
9. Umar Gul
10. Shoaib Akhtar
11. Saeed Ajmal
4 Reserves:
- Mohammad Hafeez
- Sarfraz Ahmed/Adnan Akmal as back up keeper depending on domestic performance
- Wahab Riaz
- Rana Naved Ul Hasan
That’s what they will select but who will be your reserves? And don’t u think that younis should lead?
I wrote about that match long time ago Afridi was the main culprit.
This match was suspected by some for match fixing:
http://www.cricinfo.com/pakvrsa/engine/match/299010.html
Here are the differences with the team posted above and the current team
Imran Nazir replaces Asad Shafiq
Kamran Akmal replaces Haider
Shoaib Malik replaces Mohammad Hafeez
Mohammad Yousuf replaces Misbah Ul Haq
Umar Akmal replaces Fawad Alam
I am convinced if Pakistan pick the following players for the WC, then we have a chance of winning:
1. Imran Nazir
2. Kamran Akmal (wkt)
3. Shoaib Malik
4. Younis Khan
5. Mohammad Yousuf
6. Umar Akmal
7. Shahid Afridi (capt)
8. Abdul Razzaq
9. Umar Gul
10. Shoaib Akhtar
11. Saeed Ajmal
Pakistan lost their last 8 wickets for just 46 runs in 15 overs, with this kind of leadership and team Pakistan will get white washed 5-0 in this series.
On every ball Fawad makes big left to right movement in the crease regardless of the line of the ball, he is never in line of the ball and loses his balance because of these big movements and as a result only gets nudges and pushes he is never in position to hit the ball cleanly. Why we wasted two years in developing a guy whose fundamentals are so wrong.
Both youngsters didn’t fared any better than Farhat, Shahzaib or U Akmal thats a big worry for Pakistan.
Nothing shot by Razzaq was totally clueless about the ball. Now even 220 is out of question on a flat pitch and against an average bowling side. Razzaq is a burden on the side we can only afford to play him if we have a strong top order to expect him and Afridi to restore the innings is asking for too much.
Fawad’s dance at the crease has ended he was moving too much in the crease and finally missed one which crashed onto his stumps, now 210 is a difficult proposition.
Again no match awareness. Misbah got out earlier in an attempt to hit a boundary all four last wickets were lost when the batsmen tried to score boundaries a serious problem nobody in this line up can hit power shots without taking much risk. Yousaf is missed here he alongwith Umar Akmal are two players in Pakistan line up who can produce boundaries at will. But U Akmal is not giving his 100% and Yousaf is unfit. Big problem for Pakistan we can’t depend on Misbah, Fawad and Afridi in the last 15 overs.
Minute man Afridi is gone first ball holed out on mid off.
Pakistan must score 200 by the 40th over. Fawad and Misbah should ensure that they do not waste too many deliveries. Yk was unlucky wrongly adjudged Lbw by Rauf who gave him a life when YK was in 30′s.
This is the stage where Afridi should have either come himself or sent Razzaq.
Pakistan are 154/2 the run rate is on the lower side keeping in view the batting strength of SA and the flatness of the track. Yk and Hafeez played with a lot of calmness I would have been more content if I had seen a few more boundaries. Hafeez has a major weakness of cutting the ball in air he can’t keep the ball on the ground or play it in gaps. Yk got two chances but otherwise he looked in good touch anything less than 300 will not be competitive.
Rameez Raja shared this gem on air: Shahid afridi and smith at toss, afridi looks at sa team and asks smith :who is tsotsobe? having played two games against him.
Pakistan won the toss and elected to bat. Imran Farhat, Shahzaib and Umar Akmal have been dropped, the side is almost the same as I wanted. I didn’t wanted Shahzaib to get dropped but I guess Afridi couldn’t justify his selection any more. Anyways Pakistan should have given a chance to Fawad and Asad to given them some experience.